With India’s growing population, the increase in vehicular traffic demands more effective management strategies. Therefore, selecting the appropriate barrier type is essential for ensuring smooth operations and improving security in high-traffic areas. Flap barriers and traditional gates are two popular options, each ideal for environments like corporate buildings, transportation hubs, and sports venues.
However, the effectiveness of an access control system depends on choosing the right option for your specific needs. In the following guide, we will discuss the key differences between flap barriers and traditional gates to determine which is better suited for high-traffic areas, helping you make a well-informed decision.
Key Differences Between Flap Barriers & Traditional Gates
Flap barriers and traditional gates are used to control crowds in high-traffic areas. While a flap barrier is a turnstile gate that works automatically, traditional gates often depend on manual or basic mechanised operations. To better understand each barrier system, let’s explore the major differences between the two:
Design and Aesthetics
Flap barriers are more advanced, sleek, and contemporary designs of barrier systems. These devices provide various security functions and a modern touch to any setting. They are highly compatible with high-traffic areas like corporate buildings, sports venues, and public transport stations, making them an attractive option.
Flap barriers are available in stainless steel or MS colour-coated frames, enhancing the visual appeal of the entrance. On the other hand, as the name suggests, traditional gates might appear bulky and less sophisticated, which usually clashes with the modern architectural elements of any building or venue.
Technology and Operation
Flap barriers are more suitable for high-traffic areas due to their advanced technological features. The modern gate barriers are equipped with lane LED indicators, providing clear visual signals that efficiently guide users through entry and exit points. Its drop arm feature ensures a quick response in emergencies by immediately clearing the pathway.
Moreover, its free rotation feature allows for a fast and unobstructed passage after authentication. At the same time, traditional entrance gateflap barriers lack such advanced functionality and may also cause delays during high–traffic times.
Security Features
Security is an important aspect of crowd management, and flap barriers’ high-tech security specifications meet this need. These barrier systems are equipped with a variety of authentication methods, including biometric scanners (face and finger) and card readers, offering a higher level of security. This feature significantly minimises the risk of unauthorised entry.
In contrast, traditional gates offer basic security features and rely more on physical locks and manned monitoring. They lack advanced technology, making them less effective at controlling unauthorised access. As a result, they are suitable for areas with lower security demands instead of high-traffic areas.
User Experience
Flap barrier turnstiles provide a seamless and hassle-free experience in high-traffic areas. They allow people to pass through quickly and without confusion, which is crucial during rush hours. Flap barriers’ accessibility features, like wider lanes for wheelchair access, match the specific needs of all users, including those with disabilities.
On the other hand, traditional gates require manual operation and slower processing, which often requires physical effort to open or close the gate every time a vehicle or someone approaches. This can be tiring for the operators and less accommodating during peak traffic times.
Maintenance and Durability
While flap barriers require maintenance, they are built to withstand heavy use. Their mechanical parts are protected from dust, thus reducing the need for aggressive maintenance. If you are a business or property owner, keep a frequent check on the condition of your barrier to prevent potential hazards.
At the same time, traditional gates, while sturdy, can suffer from exposure to the natural elements and frequent use. This can lead to higher long-term maintenance needs. They may require regular painting, oiling of hinges, or replacement of parts to maintain functionality.
Manpower
Due to advanced flap barrier access control systems, these devices significantly reduce the need for manpower in high-traffic areas. Once installed, they can be operated with minimal supervision. This automation allows staff to be moved to other important tasks, improving overall operational efficiency. Whereas, traditional gates demand more manpower for operating and monitoring, especially in settings with higher foot or vehicle traffic. This increases the staffing cost and potential human error.
Cost and Installation
Due to their advanced technology, flap barriers may require a higher investment at the time of installation than their counterparts. However, their long-term benefits justify the upfront cost. Flap barriers provide increased efficiency and security, leading to reduced operational costs, like manpower expenses and less frequent repairs. Moreover, their durability & low maintenance requirements ensure that they remain cost-effective over time. On the other hand, traditional gates, while less expensive initially, may incur higher costs in the long run due to increased maintenance and manpower needs.
Which Is Better for High Traffic Areas?
The choice of selection between flap barriers and traditional entrance gateflap barriers depends on your business’s specific requirements. When we talk about high-traffic areas, the ideal barrier system must include advanced and secure features for quick and safe access. With flap barriers’ automated operation, biometric scanners, and faster processing of large volumes of people, this barrier system can suit the modern requirements of your business as compared to manual operation and slower process times of traditional gates. Based on these differences, flap barriers turn out to be an ideal and best choice for high-traffic areas.
Conclusion
Flap barriers stand out as the more effective choice for many business and property owners when managing access in high-foot-traffic areas. They provide unbeaten solutions to control unauthorized entry into sensitive environments. This makes it a superior option for locations like government buildings, corporate offices, airports, and metro stations.
However, this does not mean that traditional gates are not a good option. These access systems can be used in areas with low foot traffic and when a budget is limited, but proper people management is desired. If you are looking for quality flap barrier access control systems, consider HOM Automation. We are one of the leading manufacturers and worldwide suppliers of automatic security systems in India. Contact us for detailed information.
