When it comes to access management control in facilities like commercial buildings, stadiums, public transport stations, and entertainment venues, choosing a suitable solution is crucial. Two popular options that often arise in this decision-making process are flap barriers and turnstiles. Both of these systems are designed to ensure the safety of your facility by controlling the flow of people. However, selecting between them can create a bit of confusion, as each serves different purposes and offers unique features.
So, how do you decide which one is best for your facility? For this, you have to refer to our blog, which explores the critical comparison of flap barriers vs. turnstiles. We will also discuss which option might be the best choice for your specific needs.
Flap Barriers vs. Turnstiles: Key Differences Explained
To create an effective access control system in your facility, the right barrier type is a must. Here is a detailed breakdown of the key differences between flap barriers and turnstiles:
Security Level
Flap Barrier: This access control system is an effective choice for areas with high security. Flap barriers integrated with advanced access control features like RFID cards or facial recognition technology provide an enhanced security level. Its motorised flaps make sure that only authorised people can cross the system, thus making them ideal for places like data centres or government buildings.
Turnstiles: This barrier control system extends from the floor to above an average person’s height, making it difficult to breach. However, compared to flap barriers, they offer a moderate level of security. Turnstiles consist of rotating arms or barriers that are more about crowd control rather than preventing unauthorised access.
Functionality
Flap Barriers: These security gates provide a smoother user experience, facilitating smoother traffic control. The flap barrier mechanism allows users to seamlessly gain access by swiping a card, which enables the flaps to open automatically. These barrier devices are suitable for places with professional or high-end settings.
Turnstiles: While functional, these systems may not offer the same level of convenience and security as compared to flap barriers. While entering or exiting, users need to physically push or rotate the turnstile. These systems are uncomfortable, especially for children, older adults, and those carrying heavy items. In contrast to flap barriers, turnstiles are effective for managing crowds.
Technology Integration
Flap Barriers: These devices are highly compatible with modern technologies. Depending on their design and mechanical capabilities, they can be integrated with RFID card readers and biometric systems. As a result, these security gates are a versatile option for facilities that demand high security.
Turnstiles: While turnstiles can be combined with modern technologies, their capabilities are often limited as compared to their counterparts. These systems are best suited for places where the main requirement is crowd control.
Design
Flap Barriers: This type of security gate is completely automated. Users need to have a card, ticket, or biometric identification to access the entry and exit. It features one or more horizontal flaps that open and close with each individual’s access. Generally, the flaps are made of transparent acrylic or glass, but you may also find various designs of flap barriers.
Turnstiles: This barrier device consists of rotating flat rods that revolve around a central pivot. These rods allow access to only one person at a time once an individual is properly authorised. While manual turnstiles need to be physically pushed or pulled, motorised devices are fully electrically operated. This system is made of durable stainless steel, withstanding heavy use and harsh weather conditions.
Space Utilisation
Flap Barriers: Due to the flaps’ swinging motion, these systems require more space than turnstiles. Thus making them a less ideal option for narrow areas. However, their sleeker and streamlined look makes them aesthetically pleasing to users.
Turnstiles: These security gates have a smaller footprint, which can fit into small and tighter spaces. The rotating arms of the turnstiles cover less space than the flap barriers, making them a space-efficient option. However, the exact space utilisation depends on the specific model of the barrier. So, whichever model or configuration you choose, consider the space of your facility.
Which is the Right Choice For Your Facility?
The right choice among flap barriers vs. turnstiles depends on the particular needs of your facility. Both options have their unique features & can effectively manage the flow of people while ensuring security. Flap barriers are most suitable for places that require a combination of high levels of security and modern technological features. The places include corporate buildings, data centres, and high-end commercial facilities. These barriers provide a smooth user experience and quick access control.
At the same time, turnstiles are considered best for places where crowd and basic access management are important. The places include public transport areas, shopping malls, and other high-traffic environments. Its options can range from simple to full-height turnstiles. In the end, when deciding between the two, analyse the level of security, potential traffic flow, and technology your facility may require.
Conclusion
Choosing between flap barriers and turnstiles for your facility largely depends on your specific needs, environment type, and security requirements. Flap barriers are suitable for facilities where security and speed are important. On the other hand, turnstiles are an ideal option for settings where crowd management is the main concern. By understanding their unique features and matching them with your facility’s requirements, you can choose the best security gates that ensure safety, positive user experience, and efficiency. Besides these factors, the flap barrier and turnstile price should also be on your checklist when selecting these systems.
Considering the long-term maintenance expenses of these systems helps ensure that your investment is worthy and provides positive results in the future. A well-informed decision not only saves money but also contributes to smoother operations. If you are in search of advanced and cost-effective security systems, HOM Automation is the right place for you. We are among the leading Indian manufacturers and worldwide suppliers of automatic security systems. Contact us for a free consultation!
